Tuesday, 1 January 2013
New Year's Message From Underground Man
But this is not a time for wallowing in pessimism either. It is obvious we are entering an era of momentous change as the horrors of austerity hit more and more people, in the process throwing up more and more sites for grassroots resistance. Capital is restructuring itself before our very eyes, using the economic crisis to accelerate the processes of Neoliberalism-a formation of a down trodden work force without any employment rights or a welfare safety net, with virtually all public services privatised. But capitalism has major problems in achieving this free market Utopia for the rich and powerful. As the comforts and illusions of mass consumerism and easy credit are slowly taken away and the police/security state becomes necessarily more oppressive, breaking basic human rights to contain spreading dissent, more and more people will began to see through the ideology of so-called liberal democratic capitalism. Revolt will be ungainly, messy, sometimes frightening but inevitable it will arise and out of this a counter-power (federations of workers councils, neighbourhood assemblies and radical municipalities) has a possibility to form, challenging capital and the state which sustains it and providing a genuine alternative. 2013 might be the year that we get a real glimmer of hope for the future.
Sunday, 9 December 2012
Tahrir Sq-An Inspiration For Us All
The latest news is that Morsi has backed away from his power grab; a victory for Tahrir Sq. The lesson here for us in depressingly passive austerity hit Britain with our own corrupt government of bankers, the rich, tax dodging corporations etc, is that all of us must somehow be part of creating our own 'counterpower' of the people. We can not rely on Labour and trade union leaders, certainly not the LIb-Dems to change anything. The pressure must come from below; resistance must be total. What was once seen as utopian has now become a necessity, giving a whole new meaning to the old May '68 slogan-Be Practical, Demand the Impossible!
Friday, 26 October 2012
Book Review: Rebel Cities: From The Right To The City To The Urban Revolution By David Harvey
Saturday, 6 October 2012
Thurrock Heckler: The Radical Proletarian Movement That's Needed
"We know we're not alone in wanting a broad based, radical / revolutionary proletarian movement that's an attractive proposition to ordinary working class people – we've met a few very sound comrades who share this aspiration and more importantly, recognise the urgency of the situation. The sickening thing is that we are in all probability too late to make a start in realising our vision before the economic, political, social and geo-political crises that we face all converge to create a horrific, extremely turbulent situation where the basic aim will be mere survival. However, the realisation that we may indeed be too late should act as the spur for that one last push to break through a toxic mix of complacency and inertia and kickstart the movement we need into being."
Friday, 5 October 2012
The Anti Poll Tax Moment
| Anti Poll Tax Demo: 31st March 1990 |
Friday, 21 September 2012
Saturday, 26 November 2011
All Out On 30th November! Don't Work! Don't Study!
Saturday, 16 July 2011
Book Review From Red Pepper Of Commonwealth By Michael Hardt & Antonio Negri
Saturday, 25 June 2011
Friday, 8 April 2011
Saturday, 18 December 2010
Book Review of Alain Badiou's The Communist Hypothesis by Sean Sheehan from Irish Left Review
Alain Badiou is a heavy weight philosopher of the French May'68 generation and comes from the Maoist tradition. This slim volume of essays designed to resemble Mao's 'little red book' attempts to get a grip with the Idea of Communism in a philosophical sense rather then from its disastrous practice in history. The current of Maoism running throughout (a section on the Chinese Cultural Revolution for instance) is disturbing to a libertarian Marxist like myself; but his believe that Communism cannot transcend its failures by being reduced to a Party/State comes to similar 'non-state' conclusions.Read Sean Sheehan's review from Irish Left Review here
Sunday, 14 November 2010
Friday, 2 October 2009
Dystopia Now: The Only Hope is Resistance From Below
There is a very good case to be made that the dystopian visions of science fiction are not waiting to happen in the future but exist in the here and now. Our present is not the austere Stalinist/Fascist nightmare of Orwell's 1984 but close to the gaudy hyper-capitalism and corporation dominated LA of Ridley Scott's Blade Runner and Franz Kafka's surreal faceless bureaucracies. Never before in the developed world have we been so inundated with consumer choice. There is no real limit to freedom of speech either; on the net we can read the obscure writings of the anarchists and the ultra left and at the same time the rantings of the extreme right and the insane ramblings of religious fanatics. We can vote once every four or five years for a government of our choice (the party that wins is always the one that most closely obeys the logic of capitalism) and we can say, write and get anything that money can buy. But at the most basic level no one has power or control over their lives or the real world outside the TV or computer screen.
Any form of dissent that's not the virtual, both political and cultural, peaceful or not, is safely controlled or hindered and if that fails legislated out of existence-see what happened to something as innocuous as the Big Green Gathering. Working class power residing in wildcat strikes, mass picketing and secondary action was the first to go, then the anarchic free festival and rave scene in the 80's and 90's. A burst of innovative anti-capitalist direct action in the mid and late 90's has faded after the police caught on to their tactics and began kettling demonstrators. As shopping malls and private corporate run spaces spread even the once ubiquitous left wing and single-issue campaigning stalls and leaflet drops are thinning out. Add on new anti-terrorist laws and health and safety regulations, and any semblance of popular participation or people power that does not have the approval of the authorities is made impossible without breaking some kind of law.
Clearly the idea of 'western democracy' cherished by so many is in crisis. You don't have to be an anarchist to see that voting does not work-go back to the euphoria of Tony Blair's victory in 97' and look around at the political and economic ruins surrounding us now. These days it does not take too much of a leap into the radical imagination to see that the concept of 'liberal western democracy' and the almost ritualised fetish for voting in parliamentary elections is an ideological construct keeping us chained to capitalism and neo-liberalism, making sure the complex machine ticks over nicely. Social Democracy (Old Labour, New Deals, green or otherwise) is as unrealistically Utopian as the most outrageous leftism in the brave new world of hyper-capitalism.
Rather naively I have always voted in general elections-I believed I was contributing to keeping the Tories out and just maybe as a result we would get some mild reforms in return. I had never grasped the anarchist insistence on non-voting-after all it does not take too much time or energy to put a cross on a piece of paper and scrawling some anarcho slogan on your ballet paper was to me mere gesture politics, to be read only by some bored counter of votes. At the end of the day voting did not stop you engaging in the real meaningful struggle taking place at the grass roots. But now due to the financial crisis and its fall-out, complete disillusionment even with this limited criteria for voting has set in.
Is there an alternative? I think so-the more non-voters , the more apathy there is, the clearer the message of disengagement and alienation. Negative most certainly, but all social movements and revolts start from the bed rock of disenchantment, even despair at political and economic realities. More positively we must be thinking about the coming resistance after the election as building blocks for a new left libertarian politics, one based on horizontal networks of struggle. If the cuts in the public sector (meaning also attacks on the working class in general, the unemployed and the poor, who rely on the public sector in some form to make life even marginally decent) are as bad as everyone says there going to be, resistance is guaranteed. What form or direction it will take of course cannot come with a guarantee.
But what about voting for left wing parties, Respect or Socialist Labour Party, etc or The Green Party? My views on Respect, et al can be read here. There might be a case to be made for voting for the Green Party as a protest vote, (this is academic in my case, I doubt if a Green Party candidate will be standing in my area) but for complex reasons concerning Parliamentary power and the forces of day to day conventional politics, reasons I have no time to go into in this posting, the Green Party are not a real solution purely on its own. One occupied work place or community action group are worth a thousand Green Party votes.
Saturday, 21 March 2009
G20 Summit-The Summer of Rage Starts Here?
But is this the spark of the 'Summer of Rage' as predicted by our erstwhile Constabulary? Like the professional, salaried inhabitants of an upmarket Chelsea housing estate from J.G. Ballard's novel, 'Millennium People,' the middle classes, the police predict, will increasingly engage in confrontational protest as the recession hits; the G20 summit could be the catalyst. The scenario is far fetched (for the summer of 2009 anyway); more likely the police are hyping up the threat of violence to justify cracking down hard on protesters in the coming months.
So realistically what can we expect? The TUC organised 'Put People First' demo on the 28th should be large and diverse. Hopefully its atmosphere (but probably quite not its size) will be similar to the 2003 march against the invasion of Iraq. What I'd like to see are hundreds of ordinary working people of all races and creeds taking to the streets for the first time, people who have recently been made redundant or facing re-possession, expressing their anger at the government and the bankers, with home made banners and imaginative slogans. I would like to see residents whose homes or state of mind are threatened by a new third runway at Heathrow mixing with rank and file trade unionists and eco-activists. I would like to see the construction workers who recently went on strike against labour shipped in from abroad to undercut union agreements (but leave that divisive slogan at home, lads!) Here would be a clear sign that a large scale radical movement in the UK based on day to day resistance is at least possible.
And on the 1st of April more militant demonstrators will attempt to bring the City of London to a standstill (dubbed the G20 Meltdown) by converging on the Bank of England from all sides, with a climate camp directly in the heart of the City. What would I like to see happen here? Rather then a clear divide between full-time activists and those who work in the City-office workers, bank clerks, restaurant and retail staff, cleaners etc-a full integration or merging of protest, of those who self-consciously reject the system through counter-cultural lifestyle or direct action and those who are part of 'mainstream' society but oppressed by the relations of capital, facing redundancy, cuts in pay and working conditions. I would like to see workers joining the demonstrators in a non-violent but confrontational shut down of the Square Mile!
Regardless of tub thumbing rhetoric on the G20 Meltdown's website, realistically the likeliest scenario is the hemming in of protesters into confined spaces by ranks upon ranks of riot police; a very successful tactic of crowd control learnt through bitter experience of past demonstrations and actions. No doubt minor skirmishes will occur, with a McDonald's window smashed somewhere along the way, enough to get the odd right wing tabloid and liberal protester hot under the collar, but not exactly the Paris Commune.
What I would like to see less of are the usual travails and self-conforming stereotypes of the Left. Here is a handy list:
1: The paper sellers of the Trotskyite sects, pushing their outdated rigid nostrums and competing amongst themselves for the position of the vanguard party of the proletariat. We all know what horrors that ultimately lead to; rather then representing the workers, they have only succeeded in representing the interests of a hierarchical party-a new ruling class. Meanwhile the proletariat has fragmented and diversified to the point where a revolutionary party of the industrial working class has become meaningless anyway.
2: The anarcho-counter cultural absolutists, isolated from the daily realities of capitalist oppression (work, paying the bills) by either monetary privilege (our Julian is going through his anarchist phase; he'll get over it once he gets that post in daddy's company) or an idealistic and self-rightous willingness to accept poverty, putting up with a grotty student flat or squat; the necessary privations of an uncompromising antagonism with state and society. But the mind-set created by an antagonistic lifestyle can be as vanguardist as the Trots; a sneering stand offish attitude to those millions of people with jobs and mortgages; unthinkingly embracing direct action above and beyond organisation and in consequence glorifying useless gesture politics like breaking Starbuck windows or spray-painting war memorials-easily side tracked into the blind allies of primitivism and animal rights extremism.
3: The opposite but mirror image of 2 above; the leaders and careerists in the NGO's, trade unions and mainstream political parties. Straitjacketed by corporate management theories of efficiency and perceived media respectability, they shoehorn politics into a soul destroying electoral or legalist dead end, cutting off any development of struggle that could lead to structured but libertarian organisations. Keeping protest within the boundaries of ever more restrictive legality they stifle creativity; marching from A to B, writing letters to government ministers and legal campaigns through the courts may be necessary at times but a programme so limited will stagnate and eventually be recuperated as a adjunct of the system rather then a threat to it.
But enough negativity! Let's hope the protests and actions surrounding the G20 Summit will be a success, leading not just to a 'Summer of Rage,' but years of unrest directed against an increasingly failing capitalism and its counterpart and protector, the state. Not a lashing out in pointless acts of terroristic violence, which only reflects despair and resentment, but collective resistance; a movement that really can change the world.
Friday, 17 October 2008
The Crisis of Capitalism and Network Struggles
I look to the libertarian left for inspiration-this includes varied theories and practices: anarchism, syndicalism, mutualism, 19th century utopian socialists like Fourier or William Morris, council communism, autonomous Marxism, situationism, social ecology and decentralist greens. As a libertarian then I believe organisation must come from the bottom up-horizontal networks rather then vertical top down structures. They should consist of diverse but interlinking groups able to act autonomously but co-ordinated on a national level (even the international level) via web-like structures. This is not disorganisation but a higher form of organisation, facilitated by the network nature of modern technologies like the Internet. Different groups with varied political perspectives, reformist or revolutionary, can link and disengage whenever it suits them. This would counteract centralised structures such as the Stop The War Coalition, ripe for take over by authoritarian sects and unscrupulous politicians or media personalities.

Network struggles and forms of organisation are not utopian, only existing in an imagined future or a vanished past. They exist now and in the very recent past. A classic example is the Anti-Capitalist or Anti-Globalisation movement which combines in its broad web; reformist NGO's, radical workers and peasant groups and western anarchists. Another example was the Anti Poll Tax campaign. Although The Socialist Party (Militant) was a strong influence, the Anti Poll Tax Federation was made up of hundreds of local groups consisting of working-class people, the hardest hit by this iniquitous tax. Through a mass campaign of non-payment and confrontation with the bailiffs the tax was stopped and Margaret Thatcher was ousted . A book to read on this subject is Danny Burn's, Poll Tax Rebellion, published by AK Press, which clearly sees the grass roots approach and its support of civil disobedience as the key ingredients leading to its success.
Also very much related to the above are the non-political and unconscious networks existing in our communities. If you look closely enough into British society you will find a myriad of localised campaigns against the closure of post offices, hospital wards and schools, privatisation and anti-social crime. Scattered and fragmented no doubt, lacking a political dimension, and any ultra-left glamour, but these groups are made up of everyday people in the community and directly deal with the issues affecting the lives of the working class. Any large scale struggle against capitalism in the UK will be triggered by economic and social issues affecting our daily lives. They encompass all races and religions; in fact they have the potential of bringing us together in struggle, and not dividing us like the middle class identity politics of the race relations industry. It's vital we engage and be involved with these local groups and campaigns now, otherwise fascists and religious sectarians will fill the vacuum.
And then of course there is the labour movement, probably the first widespread network of the oppressed in the modern era. Weakened externally by the onslaught of Thatcherism and by social changes and internally by Stalinism, stifling bureaucracy and legalism; but still with the potential of clashing with the exploiting class in the right conditions. Another book I would recommend very highly is Paul Mason's superb history of labour struggle and how it relates to the present day. It's called Live Working or Die Fighting: How the Working Class went Global.
Now we come to the thorny issue of reform vs. revolution and the related issue of electoral politics vs grassroots action. I consider myself to be both on the side of revolution but also a reformer. Changing the world is a painfully slow process of general low-level resistance usually based on reformist demands, but marked occasionally by huge social upheavals, insurrections or revolutions, seemingly coming out of the blue, either taking society to another level or reversing the process, as reaction (counter-revolution) sets in. Reform itself is a product of pressure from below, from the countless revolts and uprisings in history, directed against capitalism and the state by the oppressed and exploited. The ruling class and its liberal reformist parties are merely reacting to this pressure, instigating reform to hold on to its power and wealth.
But in western consumer-capitalist societies of the present day where capitalism is the very air we breath, infiltrating down to the sinews of society, fighting for radical reforms is the only practical option we have (after-all what is the demand of bringing the troops home from Iraq or going on strike for better conditions.) A shrill ultra-leftism turned on by violent insurrectionist myths and out of touch with reality (witness the fate of the new left in the 1960's) is as alienating and futile as the politician coaxing the voters with promises of tax cuts. But our radical reformist demands must be solidly based on network struggles of the oppressed and a culture of resistance as described above, and we must be prepared to take things further if the situation merits. We must never limit our struggles or our imaginations to a soul-destroying pragmatism based on conventional party politics and capitalist concepts of efficiency and managerlism.

As for the debate surrounding electoralism, I would describe my own position as tending towards anti-electoralism on the national level but not necessarily at the local. Also of note in this instance is the green movement. Although it seems if you idly flick through the newspapers or watch TV, the greens are dominated by irritating eco-consumerists and patronising middle class life stylists, they have basically got it right-we are fast approaching another crisis, the terrifying effects of climate change. The UK Green Party, wedded to electoral illusion and liberal utopianism though it is, has an interesting left wing outside of the mainstream. Unlike most of the left The Green Party has some respect and support from ordinary people and has a presence on a few local councils in working class areas. Although they have taken a major retrograde step in choosing to appoint a leader, its democratic, decentralist culture as far as I know is still healthy and has much in common with left libertarian ideas. Libertarians should try to work with rather then against the Green Party at the local level, though recognising at the same time that any alliance is extremely fragile.
Finally we must support struggles outside our own country. With the revolution in IT and the Internet it's possible to link with people around the world fighting the same battles (but with more intensity) against the ravages of global capitalism, US and Israeli imperialism, tyrannical states and political Islam. We must embrace a global culture of resistance-an alternative globalisation. Also in this time of mass migration, of whole populations on the move because of war, poverty and oppression, a priority must be to oppose all forms of racism, religious fundamentalism and anti-immigration laws in the UK.
The future is indeed a blank page and social upheavals can explode when we least expect them. Back in 1988 I attended an obscure march of at most a hundred people, against a new tax to be introduced by the Thatcher government. Two years later central London was torn asunder by the Poll Tax Riots, the culmination of a huge civil disobedience campaign, which brought down Thatcher (but unfortunately not Thatcherism.) If capitalism goes into terminal crisis we can only hope this is the launch pad of mass social struggle, making the Anti Poll Tax movement look paltry.
Friday, 10 October 2008
The Crisis of Capitalism and the State of the British Left








